AI can score every rep. Can it coach one?
Written byDan Bernoske, Bill Piacitelli, George de los Reyes, Ralph Vetsch and Chris McKenna
Executive summary
"When I first started selling, it was a few metrics. Did you make your number? And would I sit next to you on an airplane to California?" Bill Piacitelli put that scorecard in front of twelve operating partners and portfolio commercial leaders at Foley & Lardner on Park Avenue, then asked what replaces it now that every call can be transcribed.
Every call can be scored now. The hard part is getting the coaching to land with reps, and setting the rules before they start prompting. Dan Bernoske walked through a coaching tool built on call transcripts, Chris McKenna of Foley & Lardner covered AI use policies, and Ralph Vetsch, Cortado's sommelier, poured a blind flight of reds.
What the room kept asking
How do you get from scoring reps to coaching them?
Measure first, then coach, and get the coaching to the rep before the next call. Dan Bernoske walked through a coaching tool built on call transcripts. It strips out filler words and buzzwords, then scores the call so a manager knows what to coach.
The pushback was practical. One attendee said his reps don't listen, and asked how you make coaching easier and faster. Bill's point sat behind both. The use now is "not only just assessing, but also providing coaching to reps."
The scorecard then, and the scorecard now
Did you make your number?
Would I sit next to you on an airplane to California?
Dozens of KPIs and talent assessments
Call transcripts, scored and turned into coaching
Where does AI actually create value in the revenue engine?
In three places: efficiency, effectiveness and insight. Talent ran through all three. Teams that don't know what to prompt, or what context to give the model, get none of them.
The room talked a lot about talent, down to the plain version: do I have a smart person actually using AI?
Where AI creates value
Talent runs under all three. Without it, you get none of them.
Who sets the rules before reps start prompting?
Leadership, and before the rollout. Chris McKenna of Foley & Lardner walked through what happens when teams run with AI and no guardrails. Often they don't know what to prompt in the first place.
Asked how many firms have an AI use policy, the room's only guess was under half. His advice was to put the policy in place before AI reaches the whole team.
The question nobody settled: how do you show sales performance across a whole portfolio?
An attendee raised the one the speakers didn't close.
Across the portfolio
With 25 portfolio companies, sometimes 100, how do you show performance while you're raising the next fund?
Across the fund
Where are the cross-sell and upsell opportunities across the whole fund, or across several funds?
The answers about scoring one sales team don't reach that far. That's the question to bring to the next room.
A SaaS software company achieved a 13% increase in bookings per rep
Read the case studyFour questions to bring to your next portfolio review
These show whether the plan for AI in the sales team can work.
Ask the management team
What does our rep scorecard measure today: the number, activity, or what happens on the call?
How long does it take for coaching to reach a rep after a call?
Who owns our AI use policy, and does the sales team know it exists?
If our LPs asked tomorrow, could we show sales performance across the portfolio?
Who was in the room
Operating partners, portfolio CROs and commercial leaders met at Foley & Lardner's offices on Park Avenue, glass in hand before anyone sat down. Ralph Vetsch, Cortado's sommelier, poured a blind flight of California, Tuscan and Bordeaux reds. He closed the night with the reveal: what you drank, against what you thought you drank.
Every answer about scoring reps assumed you had the right reps. If you couldn't show your portfolio's sales performance tomorrow, start there.
Ideas in this recap are credited to roles. Attendee names are withheld.
Sign up for our next in-person event
Small rooms of operating partners and commercial leaders. Pick the cities you'd come to, and you'll hear first when a date is set.